Friday, October 06, 2006

Reflection To Fox Chapter 3

In chapter three of her book, Radical Reflections, Mem Fox reviews and reflects upon Donald Graves’ philosophy, look at the needs, processes, and reasons of real writers and then recreate them in the classroom. Fox talks about how important it is to let children choose their own topics, have a sense of purpose, give them an audience, and help them through the drafting and conferencing stages. Lastly she ends with a warning that these steps are not set in stone and they should remain flexible.

Chapter three of Radical Reflections seems like nothing but a copy of Graves’ book. I tend to enjoy reading Graves’ book more just because those ideas are his own which leads me to respect him as an author and a teacher. The problem may be that I am expecting Fox to say something radically profound or come up with an amazing breakthrough that just is not happening. I have read some very positive reflections about her sixth chapter, however; and I look forward to seeing what everyone is so excited about.

1 Comments:

Blogger Greg said...

You are reading critically, Coby...and using your real "voice" in your reflection, and this helps you and the rest of us to go deeper. Thanks. Some students prefer one or the other of these books. Some students get "fired up" by reading the Fox book -- and then approach the Graves book with more eagerness than they might have. My purpose was to expose you to the Fox book to light your fire and let you see a turned on language arts teacher who is authentic. The Graves book is much more about "what to do and why." If I had to choose only one book, it would have been the Graves book. But the Fox book is quite likely to help us find our voices as writers because Fox is such a good example of writing with voice. Good thinking. Keep it up. Greg

2:34 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home